Wyong's lip service to planning laws
The Community Environment Network (CEN), after completing a $27,000 historical air photo analysis into Central Coast Airport, has alleged that the former Wyong Shire Council breached the Environment Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (The Act) on no less than twelve (12) occasions – and that behaviour is being continued by the current Central Coast Council.
Warnervale aircraft landing strip.
24 April 2024
Mr Gary Chestnut, Chair of CEN, said, “It is shocking that the former Wyong Shire Council’s total disregard for the law resulted in it being fined $3000 for unauthorised clearing of conservation land in 2015. Council was also required to enter a formal undertaking to carry out remediation work to the impacted land where the unauthorised clearing took place.”
CEN is calling for Central Coast Council’s CEO, Mr David Farmer, to take steps including the withdrawal of work on the Central Coast Airport Masterplan until these potentially unlawful actions have been fully investigated.
“CEN’s primary concern is, and has always been, that Council follows the legal process that provides legal protection to the Porters Creek Wetland and at the same time provides legal rights for the operation of the airport. It is CEN’s position that the legal protection of Porters Creek Wetland and the legal rights of the airport have to be correctly communicated to the public.
The photo analysis reveals the Central Coast Council has again cleared the same area of land that the former Wyong Council was punished for clearing.
“It is shocking enough that the former Wyong Shire Council had no regard to planning law but it is beyond comprehension that the current Central Coast Council has cleared the same area of land AND failed to undertake a Part 5 Activity Assessment before clearing or relocating the End of Runway at its airport,” Mr Chestnut said.
In July 2019 the elected Councillors passed a resolution requiring the Central Coast Council to restore the 2015 area of unauthorised clearing.
However, in November 2021, the unelected Administrator attempted to rescind the Council resolution of July 2019. That rescission was bungled - the Administrator ended up rescinding a confidential minute which had nothing to do with the Central Coast Airport.
Mr Chestnut brought this mistake to Council’s attention in December 2021 and continued to correspond with the Council about this matter throughout 2022 and early 2023.
Fifteen months later Council’s CEO conceded that the report should have been written more clearly but said Council intended to clear the land for airport safety on the basis that Commonwealth legislation would override State legislation.
“Council’s attempt to hide behind Commonwealth legislation is regrettable and an ‘own goal’. If Council had bothered to undertake a Part 5 Activity Assessment, which is a statutory requirement, they would have found that the State Legislation complements the Commonwealth legislation.
“Instead, Council ignored the State planning law and cleared 2.25 ha of Endangered Ecological Community (EEC) with no justification. It appears not to be required for airport safety or fall within the status of existing use.
“In addition, Council has mowed 0.74 ha of EEC in a location where it only has the existing use status of trimming vegetation. This means Council has not taken into consideration the biodiversity impacts or offsetting on 3.00 ha of EEC.
“Why does Council and, by default, the Administrator, not follow the law when Council is responsible for applying planning law to all private citizens?” Mr Chestnut asked.
Comparing the following aerial photograph taken taken in 2023 with the aerial photograph below it, taken between 2015 to 2022, you will observe the location of the End of Runway has been relocated by Council without undertaking a Part 5 Activity Assessment.
The CEN is calling upon the CEO, David Farmer, to take the following steps: